We’re in this together! Stay safe with our COVID-19 guide

View
×

Top Custom Jewelry Sites

Custom Jewelry Sites: 118 businesses
Filter by:
Star rating
Service rating
Value rating
Shipping rating
Returns rating
Quality rating
Price
Clear All
Star rating
Service rating
Value rating
Shipping rating
Returns rating
Quality rating
Price

Moon Magic

See All Reviews
4,209 reviews
moonmagic.com
I do not like shopping, but like every man I sometimes need to choose presents for my beloved one. Moon Magic is for... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
73
Value
72
Shipping
72
Returns
52
Quality
72

Moon Magic

Jewlr

See All Reviews
37,791 reviews
jewlr.com
I recently purchased a ring for my better half through Jewlr and stupidly I messed up applying my new customer... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
40
Value
42
Shipping
40
Returns
19
Quality
36

Jewlr

Wanderer Bracelets

See All Reviews
6,180 reviews
wandererbracelets.com
Overall was an easy and smooth shopping experience. If I would say anything negative, then it would be the clarity on... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
27
Value
140
Shipping
140
Returns
1
Quality
186

Wanderer Bracelets

Jeulia

See All Reviews
6,547 reviews
jeulia.com
Excellent product that I really enjoyed. Looks and feels like a real diamond and have received tons of compliments.... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
218
Value
204
Shipping
215
Returns
121
Quality
200

Jeulia

My Jewellery Shop

See All Reviews
31 reviews
myjewelleryshop.com.au
Easy ordering online for a gift voucher which wax delivered to the recipients email on date & time nominated. read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
1
Value
0
Shipping
0
Returns
0
Quality
0

My Jewellery Shop

Betterjewelry

See All Reviews
146 reviews
betterjewelry.com
As a native "Do or Die~ Bed Stuy" lady, good quality bangles. I know when I order my bangles from you all that I am... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
6
Value
6
Shipping
6
Returns
2
Quality
6

Betterjewelry

The Pink Pigs, Jewelry, Apparel & Gifts for People who Love Animals!

See All Reviews
72 reviews
thepinkpigs.com
It's so great being able to shop and knowing the money is going to help animals. Even better that this seller has... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
2
Value
2
Shipping
2
Returns
1
Quality
2

The Pink Pigs, Jewelry, Apparel & Gifts for People who Love Animals!

Distinctive Gem

See All Reviews
90 reviews
distinctivegem.com
Jonathan and Vicki's service serves up top notch professionalism with a large side of friendly. I was looking for an... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
4
Value
4
Shipping
4
Returns
2
Quality
4

Distinctive Gem

Norse Spirit

See All Reviews
46 reviews
norsespirit.com
I ordered my husband the ring Stainless Steel Vegvisir and Jormungand ring and the craftsmanship and quality did not... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
8
Value
8
Shipping
8
Returns
4
Quality
7

Norse Spirit

watangems

See All Reviews
38 reviews
watangems.com
Fantastic through the whole process! Great transaction system and they are very helpful. Sitejabber helps consumers... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
2
Value
2
Shipping
2
Returns
2
Quality
2

watangems

Nancy Jackson Designs

See All Reviews
38 reviews
nancyjacksondesigns.com
Nancy Jackson is one of the most genuine people you will ever meet. She has a wealth of knowledge and hilarious... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
1
Value
1
Shipping
1
Returns
1
Quality
1

Nancy Jackson Designs

Best Brilliance

See All Reviews
18 reviews
bestbrilliance.com
It is not too often in life that you are able to make someone you deeply love to love you more, but I feel that just... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
2
Value
3
Shipping
2
Returns
1
Quality
3

Best Brilliance

Columbia Jewelers, Fall River, Massachusetts, USA

See All Reviews
35 reviews
columbiajewelers.net
The experience I've had with Columbia Jewelers has been amazing. Shortly after my purchase I was contacted by their... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
2
Value
2
Shipping
2
Returns
2
Quality
2

Columbia Jewelers, Fall River, Massachusetts, USA

Cleanse & Co.

See All Reviews
80 reviews
cleanseandco.com.au
I just wanted to say a massive thank you to the Cleanse&Co team, especially Hayley. I had an issue with my order so I... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
10
Value
10
Shipping
10
Returns
8
Quality
10

Cleanse & Co.

Pigeon Heart Designs

See All Reviews
20 reviews
pigeonheartdesigns.com
These rutilated quartz earrings are SO gorgeous in every possible way. The stones themselves are fantastic. The... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
0
Value
0
Shipping
0
Returns
0
Quality
0

Pigeon Heart Designs

Score Jewelry

See All Reviews
47 reviews
scorejewelry.com
"Received the ring extremely fast! It came much quicker then I thought (less then two weeks) and it's absolutely... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
36
Value
36
Shipping
36
Returns
35
Quality
35

Score Jewelry

Beharlem

See All Reviews
15 reviews
beharlem.com
The Rose Necklace is just stunning... I got mine a few days ago and Im really happy! Good quality and normal shipping... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
3
Value
3
Shipping
3
Returns
3
Quality
3

Beharlem

Bagatiba

See All Reviews
33 reviews
bagatiba.com
I learned of Bagatiba after hearing Jessie Andrews speak on Pia Baroncinis podcast. I loves the ethos behind Jessie's... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
3
Value
3
Shipping
3
Returns
2
Quality
3

Bagatiba

Cattle Cait

See All Reviews
14 reviews
cattlecait.com
This person ignored my request for a custom piece. Blocks anyone that doesn't agree with her political agenda. Her... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
0
Value
0
Shipping
0
Returns
0
Quality
0

Cattle Cait

OurCuffs

See All Reviews
33 reviews
ourcuffs.com
I purchased 2 cuffs one for each of my sisters, they wear them everyday. Having co-ordinates to a specific place that... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
13
Value
12
Shipping
13
Returns
6
Quality
12

OurCuffs

KnotznBeadz

See All Reviews
11 reviews
knotznbeadz.com
I ordered three masks (adult sizes) and they're all very well made, great quality seams, material and assembly. Also... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
0
Value
0
Shipping
0
Returns
0
Quality
0

KnotznBeadz

Rosce Jewelers

See All Reviews
25 reviews
roscejewelers.com
The quality of these jewels is excellent, my bracelet sparkles and the setting of the stones is very well done. I am... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
17
Value
17
Shipping
17
Returns
17
Quality
17

Rosce Jewelers

Edwin Novel Jewelry Design

See All Reviews
20 reviews
edwinnoveljewelrydesign.com
These guys are the plug. Edwin Novel is a one stop shop for diamonds and jewelry. While I was there I saw a... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
4
Value
3
Shipping
4
Returns
4
Quality
3

Edwin Novel Jewelry Design

Daisy BeadWorks

See All Reviews
11 reviews
daisybeadworks.com
Very happy with look and quality of my necklace. The packaging was so well done that you could send directly to... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
0
Value
0
Shipping
0
Returns
0
Quality
0

Daisy BeadWorks

Class Rings Museum

See All Reviews
5 reviews
classrings.org
I purchased this class ring as keepsake for my graduation from UVA. I was impressed with the quality of the ring, and... read more

Detailed Ratings

Service
1
Value
1
Shipping
1
Returns
1
Quality
1

Class Rings Museum

Select up to five businesses to compare

(1/5)