Custom Challenge Coins has a rating of 4.94 stars from 1,915 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally satisfied with their purchases. Reviewers satisfied with Custom Challenge Coins most frequently mention customer service, great experience, and final product. Custom Challenge Coins ranks 2nd among Coins sites.
No critical highlights yet
While I only did the money part, the rest of this whole process went very well from start to order day. Can't wait to get the coins in the mail! They (Barry) were awesome to work with! Thanks! Station 145
I'm very satisfied with your service. I ordered twice before. My first order I had a minor problem ,when I brought it to your attention it was handle with no fuss or disagreement. Your service is four stars. E.J. Kues
While I only did the money part, the rest of this whole process went very well from start to order day. Can't wait to get the coins in the mail!
They (Barry) were awesome to work with!
Thanks!
Station 145
Custom Challenge Coins were very easy to work with. They were responsive, quick in the design of my coins with no going back and forth. They were up front with their bid and did not change it when I ordered my coins. I highly recommend them if you are looking for challenge coins.
The actual checkout process is pretty annoying. There should at the very least be an option for paypal so that your customers don't have to trust the shady site that the checkout process directs you to.
Very easy to work with and the process would have been a lot quicker if I could have been more specific with what I wanted. It is perfect!
Very polite, and answered all my questions. I asked to change a color on the coin, and had the new proof right away. I have called and talked with Berry a couple times and he is very professional. We will absolutely be doing business again in the future.
Great experience…communication and follow up was quick.
We've used them for our last 5 challenge coins and have been 100% satisfied every time. They are prompt with responses and revisions, and the finished product is excellent.
I received a prompt and complete reply to my request for estimated production and shipping times. Once I had provided artwork, I quickly received a proof and was able to place my order. The entire process from my initial email to the order placement was less than a day.
Every step of this process is smooth and easy! Always willing to help you on the phone, with REAL LIVE people who answer! Coins are excellent, and almost always arrive within timeframe specified. We are a repeat customer who can't say enough good things about this company and the people handling the phones. (R.I. Fire Instructors Assoc.)
This is my 2nd order recently, and my agency has used this company in the past. The design process was wonderful, with any slight modifications or requests made quickly. Quality finished product on the 1st order, and expect nothing less with this one!
I have now used Custom Challenge Coins 3 times for different youth sports leagues and teams. They are patient and accommodating with revisions, respond quickly with answers and artwork, get the coins delivered quickly, and do beautiful work. Highly recommended!
I had a great experience and will definitely recommend this company
We have worked with Custom Challenge Coins twice and both times have been great experiences.
Easy design and pricing tools. Prompt replies to questions and minor redesign.
Looking forward to receiving the finished products.
It was a pleasure working with my contact. Very professional and very helpful.
I ordered challenge coins from CoinsMadeYourWay for my Homebrew club in Korea a few years back and was very pleased with that experience. I am now living in Germany and immediately thought of CoinsMadeYourWay when my company decided to make a set of Challenge Coins for our team in Europe. Thankful the flyer was still in the plastic sleeve for my last couple coins. Once again, great experience, helpful input on our design, and easy ordering!
Once again, you guys are a pleasure to work with. Look forward to my next order.
Great customer service and fast proofs returns. Changes are done quickly as well
They made the process so easy a caveman could do it.
The challenge coin I designed needed 6 revisions, mainly due to preferences from a separate client. Custom Challenge Coins took each revision, no questions asked, and did a fantastic job with communication throughout the entire process. I'm really impressed!
This is our 3rd time ordering our Custom Challenge Coins and we have been extremely satisified with every order. They have always been very professional and helpful while we placed our orders. I would highly recommened using them. A 5 Star Rating from our company.
Several turns or versions. Very helpful with changes to the design. Fast and responsive.
We originally order coins a few years ago. Barry Rainwater, our sales rep, was awesome to deal with and help us design our coin. Years later, we attempted to order more there was no issues with recalling the original order and it made it very easy. I would recommend this company to anyone who is looking to get coins made.
Communication was easy, and most important--- their art person did a really nice job of turning my sketch into a respectable image for the coin. All very professional. My second coin with these guys.
I'm very satisfied with your service. I ordered twice before. My first order I had a minor
problem ,when I brought it to your attention it was handle with no fuss or disagreement.
Your service is four stars.
E.J. Kues