• Magick Planet

Magick Planet

Overview

Magick Planet has a rating of 2.04 stars from 53 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally dissatisfied with their purchases. Reviewers complaining about Magick Planet most frequently mention customer service problems. Magick Planet ranks 58th among Magic sites.

  • Service
    41
  • Value
    37
  • Shipping
    40
  • Returns
    26
  • Quality
    32

This company responds to reviews on average within 1 hour

Positive reviews (last 12 months): 20%
Positive
4
Neutral
1
Negative
15
8
See all photos
How would you rate Magick Planet?
Top Positive Review

“Never had a problem”

Tawni L.
2/16/24

I've only ordered once from Magick.com, but I never had a problem with my order. My tarot cards came in perfect condition, and my free crystal was included as well. Compared to other online sites, they have the lowest prices available. I'm not sure why so many people have had problems with them.

Top Critical Review

“Never delivered”

Patrícia S.
2/24/24

Placed an order, and never received it, contact with the company resulted in many issues and no refund, they block you from social media channels after telling you more lies. Still my money

Reviews (53)

Rating

Timeframe

Other

Thumbnail of user patriciaspicacci
1 review
0 helpful votes
February 24th, 2024

Placed an order, and never received it, contact with the company resulted in many issues and no refund, they block you from social media channels after telling you more lies. Still my money

Tip for consumers:
Liars!!!

Products used:
I have never received my order

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user rachelm963
Rachel M. – Magick Planet Rep

I can not find an open order for a Patricia S., do you possibly have another name you go by?

Thumbnail of user honestc10
1 review
2 helpful votes
April 12th, 2024
Verified purchase

I am in the habit of only leaving positive reviews for businesses. Unfortunately, this experience was so bad I am leaving a poor review just in the hopes that it spares someone else the hassle and jerking around that I've experienced. Magick.com is either a scam or just poorly run. I placed an order 3/4. It is now 4/12 and my order still has not shipped. Emails to customer service either blame their promo sale or shipping for the delays. Of course, they have no problem collecting money the day of the order, even though a full month after placing the order it's yet to be sent. I'd rather pay full price than deal with this if this is their idea of "savings". I gave the company fair warning that I would dispute the charge with my credit card company, waited three business days and still heard nothing. So yeah… well done, Magick. You deserve this unflattering review.

Service
Value
Shipping
Thumbnail of user katies1215
1 review
2 helpful votes
January 18th, 2024

Scammers. Lie and say they will ship your item in 5 days, buts it's been 4 weeks since order was placed. Because the items are fake and ordered from china, not the publisher. When china makes your items (and half prints your tarot cards so you don't don't what you have) they send them. Magick waits a month and ships it to you. Send emails claiming the "warehouse" is behind but there is no warehouse! This company does not have any employees listed on their government documents so maybe the aliens are running the magical warehouse. Your waiting for the shipment from china to arrive at least be honest and refund me before I report your fake "warehouse" where we can sort out the taxes you haven't paid for your alien warehouse workers. Good luck

Products used:
Refund

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user rachelm963
Rachel M. – Magick Planet Rep

Hi Katie

I do see that we cancelled your order that was placed 2 weeks ago, and you were completely aware of the longer processing time frame. Your order was getting ready to be picked up but after your multiple emails (13 email in a row that were all verbally abusive) in a row cussing out our customer service reps, and the only contact we had with you since your initial order 2 weeks ago, we already issued a refund this afternoon.

We have a warehouse, and we do pay our taxes. We do have employee's and we file our monthly payroll taxes. We are licensed with every publisher and have NEVER purchased from China or anywhere else. All our items come directly from the publishers. Unfortunately, due to your harassment, you did not receive your order 1st order to make claims which are slanderous.

I hope your move out of the country is success, and that you find happiness there.

Thumbnail of user melissac2718
1 review
2 helpful votes
December 25th, 2023
• Updated review

Lies multiple times about why you didn't get your order and then tells you another reason in an hour or two, one hand does not know what the other is doing. Do not purchase from this company, Scammers To Rachel, there were not 17 smooth orders or delivries, and you responded to my review on Christmas to my first review, that's why I left another and a message to you. I would not give any of my orders a good review as they all took an enormous amount of time to get, one I waited 20 days after the email saying that it shipped and contacted MP. They said they were having trouble with their shipping partner, but seconds after I got the response, I got another email saying the item shipped and it still took another 20 days to receive the item. Timely? Not hardly. Your excuses are unrealistic when multiple contacts give multiple excuses. I will never order from you again. Never refer anyone to use your company and you are the one who responded on Christmas day to my first review, not me.

Tip for consumers:
This company responds with bogus answers, total scammers do not use this company

Products used:
None, was told they were out of stock one time and told the order wasn't pulled another, Told on another the order had been shipped, waiting for shipping company but it never came

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user rachelm963
Rachel M. – Magick Planet Rep

Customer is leaving another review for the same order she left a previous review for on October 23rd. She received her refund for this order on October 18. Once again, she has had 17 successful orders (still looking for the reviews she left for those 17 positive experiences), and her 18th order had an issue of being delayed, which she stated she would wait, then changed her mind at which time, we issued a refund immediately.

No refund no merchandise
October 17th, 2023
• Previous review

Placed an order, and never received it, contact with the company resulted in many issues and no refund, they block you from social media channels after telling you more lies. DO NOT PURCHASE FROM THIS COMPANY. File a BBB complaint against them. Let others know they are not a reputable company by any means.

Tip for consumers:
Scam artists across the board, no one should be treated the way they treat their customers, take your money and never give you the merchandise

Products used:
None, I never received them

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user tawnilamb22
1 review
0 helpful votes
February 16th, 2024

I've only ordered once from Magick.com, but I never had a problem with my order. My tarot cards came in perfect condition, and my free crystal was included as well. Compared to other online sites, they have the lowest prices available. I'm not sure why so many people have had problems with them.

Products used:
Tarot cards

Service
Value
Shipping
Quality
Thumbnail of user rachelm963
Rachel M. – Magick Planet Rep

Thank you so much Tawni! We appreciate your support!

Thumbnail of user janej492
1 review
9 helpful votes
June 15th, 2023
Verified purchase

Paid as much for expedited shipping as the cost of the item to ensure that I receive it in time. This was nearly a week ago. No movement, no update email, but they are now spamming my inbox with sales and daily specials. Avoid!

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user rachelm963
Rachel M. – Magick Planet Rep

When updating shipping to an expedited service, it does state on the website that it does NOT expedite processing, nor put your order in front of other orders. As with ANY company that up you upgrade shipping, it ONLY affects the time it is in transit to you.

Thumbnail of user austinl260
1 review
4 helpful votes
February 7th, 2023
Verified purchase

I only recently tried purchasing from Magick.com. I had a couple of good experiences initially but then... with a couple of subsequent orders (specifically MP******* and MP*******) things took a turn for the worst.
In summary: I was sent e-mail messages that the orders had shipped, but were held up "somewhere" in the shipping process/system. Several calls to customer service (same person each time) resulted in the "familiar song and dance" that included how they would try to fix the problem as soon as possible by sending the order again. The explanation also included a comment related to how difficult it can be to get people to their job (in reference to their shipping department).
NOTHING HAPPENED. So, after another week I cancelled the orders and will not consider purchasing from Magick.com again at any cost.
From my perspective, no one is doing their job there and I would hope this behavior would matter to Magick.com's management/owner (unless of course the owner is the same person I spoke to in customer service).

Tip for consumers:
Easy to use.

Products used:
Fortune Telling Cards

Service
Shipping
Thumbnail of user rachelm963
Rachel M. – Magick Planet Rep

This customer placed 5 orders with us, out of the 5 one order was lost and we were working on sending a replacement. Customer called and became extremely rude with a phone representative and demanded we cancel his order. Per his request, we canceled his order. In addition, we canceled his remaining order that he had placed a couple days prior that was already prepared to ship because we can not have customers verbally abusing our employee's.

Thumbnail of user isabelk55
1 review
7 helpful votes
May 15th, 2023

I ordered in April.Worst customer service actually non existent customer service. The order still has not been received and all I get is the runaround emails with all kind of excuses from products out of stock, held at customs etc. I called the number listed on their website, but nobody answers the phone. I think Magick.com is a scam just to get your money. Check BBB website, there are plenty of complaints from customers. I call magick.com a plain THIEF and a SCAMMER!

Service
Value
Thumbnail of user rachelm963
Rachel M. – Magick Planet Rep

Hi Isabel,

Sorry you had an issue with the one order that was held up by customs. I'm glad to see that you have placed over 20 orders with us and even several more over the last month or two.

Thumbnail of user chachab3
1 review
16 helpful votes
April 12th, 2022

Their go to excuse when you look for your order is "oh UPS LOST IT" YOU WOULD THINK BY NOW (IF THAT WERE TRUE) THEY WOULD SWITCH CARRIERS. It's Bs tho - that's their go-to excuse for EVERY ORDER. It's the excuse I've received all 4 times so I can no longer keep shopping here - their lack of accountability is crazy. Just ADMIT you need longer time to process - stop lying about it.

Tip for consumers:
Go elsewhere - no transparency here

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user lakishaj25
1 review
4 helpful votes
April 28th, 2023

I placed my order on April 16th and I'm still waiting on an email with a tracking number. It has been way longer than the 1-5 business days that the site states that it takes to ship. It's the 28th of April and still no word. This is crazy. I will be seeking business elsewhere.

Shipping
Thumbnail of user hausofecdysis
1 review
0 helpful votes
July 24th, 2023

So after a MONTH of waiting for my package and lack of proper communication from this company, I finally got my order. But it wasn't even CORRECT! With them trying to prove a point and continue to be ignorant, they never said anything about any items being replaced! I ordered an 8oz bottle of road opener wash and what did they give me?! A random $#*! bottle of Alcanfor that leaked in my damn package. I'm sure they'll find an excuse like they always do instead of admitting they're wrong and correcting it like a professional company. It's been nothing but BS from them.

Tip for consumers:
The package had the correct address on it- my new address. so there was no reason it should have gotten shipped to the old address, they’re just incompetent.

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user rachelm963
Rachel M. – Magick Planet Rep

Customer is now stating she received it, when USPS shows it was delivered on the 17th. Customer also states that it had the new address but went to the old address. We do not handle deliveries for the post office, so that would be USPS not us.

This customer did receive her package which was sent to the address that was entered at the time she placed her order. We did attempted to change the address per her request even after the label had been created but the order had been picked up by the carrier. Customer's statement that they upgraded to expedited is false, she chose "Parcel Select Ground" and delivery ranges from 2–8 days. Customer refuses to have her partner contact her "FAMILY" to refused the shipment or have them return it. Customer demanded to issue a refund and for us to ship her another package, while her finance's family keeps the other.

Thumbnail of user abubakarsalis4424
1 review
0 helpful votes
May 14th, 2023

Quite literally a top experience I've had with an occult/witch/magick store. I've purchased more than 50+ times with Magick over the several years they have been in business. I've had maybe 1-2 slow ships but overall they are very quick. I'm sure the reviews you're reading here are single time mishaps but Magick is a very good company to buy from. They also recieve releases before Amazon so I'm always sure I will get a copy before the public which is very cool.

Products used:
I purchased the Buffy Tarot but I've purchased a bunch of items from lodestones to herbs over the years.

Service
Value
Shipping
Quality
Thumbnail of user christianag5
1 review
21 helpful votes
March 31st, 2021
Verified purchase

I waited 2 weeks before writing them about the fact that UPS still didn't have my package in the system. Instead of taking ownership of the mess-up they said UPS had lost it & they were reshipping it, but they were still using the same tracking number? Not possible. When I confronted them about it, they told me I was rude & they didn't want my patronage. I might not be a store ordering tons of product but I should be treated with respect. I'm still waiting 3 weeks after placing my order... I might have saved a couple bucks but it is NOT worth it!

Thumbnail of user tiffanyl554
1 review
3 helpful votes
July 27th, 2023

I placed my Order May 24,2023 by June 6,2023 it was sitting in Hawthorne, CA. As of Today July 22,2023 MY TWO DECKS THAT I HAVE NOT RECEIVED IS STILL SITTING IN HAWTHORNE,CA! My first couple emails were answered by Isobel stating they were having shipping issues which is understandable. When I didn't see any movement two weeks after that I sent more emails and two phone calls…NOTHING…but they can send SPAM to my email. I HAVE ADDED PHOTOS…I KEEP RECEIPTS. I even asked for a refund…NO RESPONSE! I WILL BE REACHING OUT TO MY FAMILY ATTORNEY BECAUSE THIS IS UNACCEPTABLE. STICK TO AMAZON YAL OR A BOTANICA SHOP. THESE PEOPLE ARE TERRIBLE. COME ON AND RESPOND RACHEL M. SINCE YOU SEEM TO BE THE SPOKES PERSON…

Tip for consumers:
Magick Planet is a horrible business

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user dionneg29
1 review
2 helpful votes
July 7th, 2023
Verified purchase

I have placed three orders with this store. The first two went smooth and no complaints. This time it has been almost a month since I ordered. My order still says shipping pending since June 27, I ordered on June 15. I emailed. This was the response " have sent a request to my shipping department to confirm that your order has been picked up by our carrier. When preparing to ship an order, they print the label, pull the item, package, and then contact our carrier. So, there could be a delay from the time it prints, and the carrier picks it up. I do know they have also had a couple restock shipments that were delayed.

In addition, we have been informed by USPS that they are experiencing a delay in updating the tracking numbers. I have noticed that quite a few deliveries have also not been scanned until they were delivered.

Isabel"

Not a great shipping experience this time.

Products used:
Tarot cards

Service
Shipping
Returns
Thumbnail of user rachelm963
Rachel M. – Magick Planet Rep

As customer stated, first 2 orders went very smoothly, no issues (no positive reviews written). Customer notified us on 7/6 that she had not received her order from, and our rep responded and submitted a trace request. Customer did respond the very next day by stating she was given poor customer service, although she received a response the same day she emailed and a replacement was requested (and sent) and stated the following:

"I have ordered from you before twice and the shipping did not take this long. This is very disappointing and poor customer service. It’s almost a month since I ordered. I will not be ordering from this store any more. I will also be leaving a negative review on whatever social media sites I can find about this issue."

Thumbnail of user amandad1603
1 review
0 helpful votes
March 8th, 2023
Verified purchase

Had a few packages take a little longer than normal but they explained they had a delay with the item which was totally fine. The item arrived in great condition and I was so excited to use my deck! Patience is virtue

Products used:
oracle deck

Service
Value
Shipping
Quality
Thumbnail of user rachelm963
Rachel M. – Magick Planet Rep

Thank you!

Thumbnail of user lisalaud66
1 review
3 helpful votes
May 15th, 2023

Spent $25 in loop on 5/4/23 never brought to carrier. Waiting for a response. 3rd time ordering with magick and same thing happened with another order and out $8 before.

MP*******

Tip for consumers:
Magick site

Products used:
Magick site

Service
Shipping
Thumbnail of user jillb988
2 reviews
11 helpful votes
November 4th, 2022

I usually buy from original botanica and never had any problems but I thought I would give this company a try because of their sale. The site said it would email within 1-5 days... well, I'm on day five and nothing to report. I sent an email and received a snotty reply. Needless to say I'll be at the bank disputing the charge. Lesson learned that cheaper isn't always better.

Service
Value
Thumbnail of user rachelm963
Rachel M. – Magick Planet Rep

This customer placed an order on Monday. We responded that orders take 1-5 business days to ship. This was scheduled to ship today which is the 4th business day (Friday). There was no snotty response.

Thumbnail of user andreag793
1 review
17 helpful votes
March 27th, 2022

I ordered from this site back in 2020 and did a credit card dispute after they claimed they shipped my order but then admitted they didn't even have the items in stock and directly after, refused to acknowledge my request to cancel the order. After the cancellation request AND credit card dispute with my bank that they never responded to, they still sent me the items THEN had someone named Rachel proceed to harass me via email, which INSANELY went as far as actually contacting the local Sheriff claiming I stole those items they sent me, claiming I never tried to cancel even though I provided proof that I did, then INSANELY put my personal information, phone #, email, and address as well as other customer's information on a website which is absolutely disgusting, lacks integrity and I will be taking action against immediately.

Tip for consumers:
I do not recommend

Service
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user elizab11
4 reviews
35 helpful votes
August 9th, 2022
Verified purchase

I placed an order July 29th. It is now August 10th. The order has not moved since the 4th. They do that because they want people to pay an outragous amount for shipping. They do not want you to do the free shipping... Dishonest gain. Im about ready to file a dispute and get my money back. Im telling you... dont order from here. My order was 93 dollars so it was not a small order for a personal order. Dirty... I mean do you really want a bad reputation for your company? Just saying. Not happening with me again.

Shipping
Thumbnail of user rachelm963
Rachel M. – Magick Planet Rep

We do not have any emails from an Eliza B nor do we have any orders for this name. If you are having an issue with your order, please email us at support@magick.com so we can resolve.

Thumbnail of user rachaels51
2 reviews
12 helpful votes
May 18th, 2023
Verified purchase

My first order, I bought 4 decks and received 3. Prices are low, so I ordered 8 more decks after that, prepared to wait 2 or 3 weeks for shipping. I received NO decks and no information, though I tried to contact the company by phone and email. No luck. I disputed payment for 8 decks with my credit card company, and the money was refunded quickly. Magick.com contacted me (seems they have changed their name? RED FLAG) after that. They claimed the items had been shipped, while the shipping company clearly shows that a shipping slip was merely created but nothing was shipped. Magick.com then said the first missing deck was back-ordered (4 weeks after I placed the order), and they will not refund the money. They then tried to convince me that I would have to pay for the 8 decks I did not receive and made it obvious that this is either a scam or they are not equipped to be in business. Try Ebay--better prices, service, and reputation.

Products used:
Tarot cards

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user carav28
1 review
6 helpful votes
March 7th, 2023

Magick.com (aka Magickplanet.com) is a scam. They lie to you through their teeth all the time. Read other reviews. I've placed 2 orders, and it takes weeks (about 4) before they ship. When you contact them, you get one excuse after another. For the first order, "the package was stolen from USPS." For the second order, "they were waiting for an item to be in-stock" before they could ship, but it was shown as in-stock on their website.

I also had a much bigger and worse problem when I made a return to them. They provided a prepaid return label for USPS. The package "disappeared" in transit. I contacted USPS, who told me after several weeks that it was a "really strange tracking number," and that it had been handed off to Fedex. I contacted Fedex, and the bad tracking number made it impossible for me to file a claim. So after FINALLY getting through to a live person, they told me Magick had to file a Fedex claim. I spent 1.5+ months contacting Magick about filing the Fedex claim, and they kept putting me off and not responding. Finally, Isabel, who I had been in contact with most, told me she would file the claim. Right after that, Isabel and Magick stopped responding to my emails altogether. This remains unresolved after months of my efforts.

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user rachelm963
Rachel M. – Magick Planet Rep

This customer placed an order in July, and requested to return a couple items. We sent a return label on Aug 11th using USPS and the label was purchased through their authorized site. Customer emailed mid-January claiming she dropped it with USPS in August (5 months previously) but claims USPS told her they gave it to Fed-Ex. Fed-Ex does not delivery USPS First Class packages, and they have no record of this package at Fed-Ex nor USPS. I tried explaining this to the customer but she became extremely hostile, and unwilling to admit she possibly dropped it off at the wrong location.

Thumbnail of user lizl297
1 review
0 helpful votes
January 25th, 2023

Perfect selection of decks! Used a coupon code so the order was cheaper than Amazon. Very happy with the service, will definetly buy again. +++

Tip for consumers:
Use the coupon codes

Products used:
Tarot decks

Service
Value
Shipping
Quality
Thumbnail of user anyaew
1 review
2 helpful votes
July 28th, 2023

The issue with this company is they can never admit when they're wrong. First of all, I waited about a month to get my package. And they apparently think it's funny for me to be at no contact with my fiancé's family due to their racism as the company's customer service reps keep putting quotations around words, as if to mock me. (My fiancé and I made a big move half way across the country and i sent the package to her family's house in my fiancé's name as that would be the last place she would be to get the remainder of her stuff before we left) Second, little to no communication and when you do get a reply, it's a deflection. I ordered an 8oz bottle of Road Opener wash and they gave NO indication that the item would be replaced (just a random refund of $4 with no other word about it)- they instead slapped a random wash in the box as if it would be fine. Nothing was sealed so it leaked in my package. Third, I ordered devil's CLAW root and they placed an incorrectly labeled item in my box which turns out to be devil's CLUB! (I will provide pictures below). Devil's CLAW and Devil's CLUB don't even LOOK similar. One looks like pieces of chopped root and the other looks like tree bark (again, providing pics of what I ordered vs what I received) I am now waiting even longer for a reply back in regards of getting my correct items. They always have a rebuttal or a pathetic excuse instead of admitting they messed up. If they had just communicated and fixed the issues instead of turning everything into tit-for-tat they wouldn't be getting all these 1 star reviews. Period. Get it together. And I'm sure the reply from them (if I get one) will just be a bunch of excuses to get the fingers pointed away from them.

Thumbnail of user yuofonga
1 review
1 helpful vote
February 9th, 2022

Very competitive prices. I have made many orders and have always been pleased. One order looked like it was lost, so I emailed Magick. They didn't ask me to be patient and wait it out; they went ahead and resent the entire order, which was a large one. They did use the same tracking information, which took a few more days to update but everything worked out. The free shipping is media mail so it may take awhile if you're on the East Coast, but still so worth it.

Tip for consumers:
Sometimes the free crystals can be hard to spot, especially if it's a large order with lots of wrapping.

Products used:
Tarot decks

Service
Value
Shipping
Quality
Thumbnail of user rachelm963
Rachel M. – Magick Planet Rep

Thanks so much!

Sitejabber for Business

Gain trust and grow your business with customer reviews.

From the business

Company Representative

Thumbnail of user rachelm963
Rachel M.
Typically responds within 1 hour

How do I know I can trust these reviews about Magick Planet?

  • Sitejabber’s sole mission is to increase online transparency for buyers and businesses
  • Sitejabber has helped over 200M buyers make better purchasing decisions online
  • Suspicious reviews are flagged by our algorithms, moderators, and community members
Have a question about Magick Planet?