• Sole Society

Overview

Sole Society has a rating of 1.23 stars from 64 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally dissatisfied with their purchases. Reviewers complaining about Sole Society most frequently mention customer service, return policy, and store credit problems. Sole Society ranks 715th among Shoes sites.

  • Service
    7
  • Value
    7
  • Shipping
    7
  • Returns
    6
  • Quality
    7

This company does not typically respond to reviews

Positive reviews (last 12 months): 0%
Positive
0
Neutral
0
Negative
1
See all photos

What reviewers want you to know

Positive highlights

No positive highlights yet

Critical highlights

  • Sole Society Customer Service are idiots, have nasty attitudes.
How would you rate Sole Society?
Top Positive Review

“Great Lacie Weekender Bag”

Gillian A.
3/5/20

I ordered the lacie weekender bag and I love it. It is great quality and feels and looks like real leather although it is vegan. I was concerned about purchasing from them after seeing these reviews but I personally thought it was great and the bag i purchased is definitely worth the money.

Top Critical Review

“Coming apart”

Jennifer P.
3/22/24

These have been a sitting on my closet I can't remember if I wore them even once. The leather is peeling off. Falling off in droves. Must be plastic instead. Horrible quality. The sole isn't worn so it's not from over wear, it's due to quality.

Reviews (64)

Rating

Timeframe

Other

Reviews that mention popular keywords

customer service (18)
Thumbnail of user jenniferp3205
1 review
0 helpful votes
March 22nd, 2024

These have been a sitting on my closet I can't remember if I wore them even once. The leather is peeling off. Falling off in droves. Must be plastic instead. Horrible quality. The sole isn't worn so it's not from over wear, it's due to quality.

Thumbnail of user samantap6
1 review
0 helpful votes
August 26th, 2020

I purchased a pair of boots which they first sent me each boot in a different size, returned those and had them send me the correct size. They didn't fit well, so I returned those as well. Because I had returned the wrong size ones (not my fault) and exchanged for the correct size, they said they could not refund me the money, and instead could only issue me a store credit.
Don't buy from this store! Their policies are flimsy and designed to get you. I should not be penalized for their error.

Thumbnail of user suzt1
1 review
0 helpful votes
October 7th, 2020

NEVER received order from 6 months ago. Unable to talk to anyone or communicate regarding situation. THATS STEALING!

Thumbnail of user kristent52
1 review
13 helpful votes
February 11th, 2019

I just ordered several pairs of shoes from Sole Society. They were all final sale, so I can't return them. I assumed (silly me) that these were great shoes from the glowing reviews they receive on their website. These are very cheaply made shoes with poor designs. I'm now stuck with these junk shoes that I can't do anything with. The sizing is right, but there's odd issues that show up that make wearing the shoes impossible like one pair is so narrow I can barely fit my already narrow feet in and a pair that has stretched out straps that do not fit anyone. Please stay away from this company.

Thumbnail of user alesheam
a m.
1 review
9 helpful votes
April 9th, 2018

I read the other reviews on here, and thought I'd test my luck I guess. I ordered taupe ankle boots in a size 5. What did they send me, though? A size 9. Definitely the same thing, right? I'm super disappointed. The boots look cute, but the insides look kind of cheap, so I can't really test out the wear of them. $50 dollars just gone. I'll have to give these to my boyfriend's mom since they are her size.

Tip for consumers:
Don't buy final sales from them even if they show they have your size. They will send you the wrong size and can't return them because of the final sale tag.

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user melissag460
1 review
4 helpful votes
November 18th, 2019

I have never ordered boots online, but I found a pair in a catalog that looked so cute. They arrived quickly, but when I opened the box, I found these $130 boots had little holes in the leather and they looked like they had been worn and painted. Everybody in my office was watching me open them and it was embarrassing to say the least to see such poor quality for the extreme price. I'm wondering if the positive reviews are even legit. Maybe they need to be reported.

Thumbnail of user bethd57
2 reviews
14 helpful votes
September 3rd, 2017

I recently reviewed three styles I recently purchased. Two reviews were favorable - 5 stars - since the shoes were cute and fit well. The third review was mediocre - 3 stars - since the shoes are hard to wear. Only the favorable reviews now appear on their site! Don't rely on the ratings or reviews.

Thumbnail of user christyt52
1 review
0 helpful votes
August 25th, 2020

I received three email like the below. I placed an order with you years ago and have not ordered since. I also do not have a card that ends with 8/25/2020. BAD customer service.

HELLO.

YOU HAVE TO VERIFY YOUR CREDIT CARD WITH THE DATE OF 08/25/2020.
WE HAVE TO DO THIS FOR YOUR PAST ORDERS AND CURRENT ORDERS. WE APOLOGIZE FOR ANY INCONVENIENCE...
THIS IS A PROCESS THAT MUST BE FOLLOWED DUE TO YOUR ACCOUNT SECURITY AND NEW LAWS.

Thumbnail of user juliej172
1 review
10 helpful votes
June 15th, 2019

Sole Society has a terrible return policy. I ordered 2 pairs of shoes from them recently. I liked one pair but the other did not look good on my foot. When I went to return them, they took a 15% discount off the price, even though I paid full price for them, and then charged me $7.95 for the return shipping label. I maybe could have lived with the charge for the return label (although other retailers don't do that), but I am pissed that they took 15% off the price. I can't help it they were full price when I paid for them and 15% off when I returned them. I should have been refunded the price I paid. I will never order from them again. Plenty of other options out there.

Thumbnail of user hollys311
1 review
0 helpful votes
June 19th, 2020

Sole Society allows you to purchase with Afterpay. However nightmare if you return shoes to DSW and results in credit. Listed on packing slip.
Sole Society will not report credit to Afterpay. DSW will issue credit to your bank and Sole Society wants you to continue paying full amount to Afterpay.
Afterpay expects Merchant to report credit but Sole Society does not report.
Interesting Sole Society is part of DSW however companies do not work together
They are ripping off consumers still making you pay full amount. If you buy from Sole Society you will be short changed on returns.
Sole Society Customer Service are idiots, have nasty attitudes. Cannot understand simple math and company policies. Returns to DSW for their merchandise is easier reports to Afterpay right away don't expect Sole Society to do so if at all.

Thumbnail of user miac7
CustomerCare -. – Sole Society Rep

Dear Holly S-
Sorry to hear that you are not satisfied with your experience. However, the facts are that you paid with Afterpay and chose to return/exchange your purchase at a DSW store. At the store, we issued a partial DSW merchandise credit refund towards your DSW purchase and refunded the rest back to your credit card. In fact, we spoke about how the process works over the phone for 45 minutes. We are happy to reverse the credit card refund we issued and credit your Afterpay account. Feel free to email us back and will take care of the credit card refund reversal.

Best,

- Sole Society

Thumbnail of user angies20
10 reviews
85 helpful votes
April 9th, 2015

The quality of these shoes is the same as the cheapie discount sites so why did I pay $70 for a pair of wedges? RETURNED FOR A FULL REFUND. I will not be purchasing from this site again.

Thumbnail of user krisg135
1 review
5 helpful votes
October 20th, 2019

So, I've NEVER been able to complete an order with Sole Society. Once in 2018, my order showed that it went through, but then it was cancelled unexpectedly and I was refunded the full amount. I tried again on Friday and one order was processed through Afterpay, but Sole Society did not complete my order. I've tried numerous times since to place an order without Afterpay and I continue to get "error messages" and "general DECLINE of card" (btw, the cards has more than enough to pay for the shoes) Customer service is NO help and they act like, "Omg, I'm so sorry, I can't believe this is happening!" OR I get a sarcastic chat girl! So tired of them. Glad I read the reviews! So long Sole Society! They better keep all of those emails out of my box!

Thumbnail of user miac7
CustomerCare -. – Sole Society Rep

Hi Kris!

I'm very sorry to hear that you have had such a bad experience with our company. I would love to look further into this and provide a clear explanation as to what seems to be the issue. I'd be very thankful if you allow the opportunity for this to be rectified. Please send a direct message with your email address and first and last name so that I can help further!

Thanks,
Sole Society Management

Thumbnail of user lizc136
1 review
1 helpful vote
October 19th, 2019

I have never given a one star review ever, but this place is ridiculous.
I was sent a 15% off code. The site applied the code and then at checkout denied the code, And charged full price. When I complained I was told omg! That sometimes happens I will refund it promptly to your account' a week later all 3 pairs of shoes still had not shipped, money still had not been refunded. I ask again we are moving wear houses and don't know when your items will ship, money will be refunded when they ship' 4 days later (I'm not kidding) products finally ship, they don't rush, they don't put the shipping I requested that was 3 days, they put on ground... and they STILL haven't refunded the 15% that they offered.
So now 3 weeks later I still have NO shoes, and NO refund.
That's one hell of a way to make a person who bought 3 pairs of shoes a repeat customer!

Thumbnail of user miac7
CustomerCare -. – Sole Society Rep

Hi Liz!

I'm so sorry to hear about the delay with your order and refund. Please send over your email address and first and last name via direct message and I will be more than happy to assist with this.

Thanks,
Sole Society Management

Thumbnail of user stacia8
1 review
6 helpful votes
July 5th, 2018

The quality of these shoes are terrible. There is no grip at the bottom and some of the suede was already starting to peel. Forget about customer service, they will not respond for days and give you generic answers. A total scam!

Thumbnail of user miac7
CustomerCare -. – Sole Society Rep

Hi Stacy! So sorry to hear about your experience with us. In regards to the quality of the shoes, we would love to help you get a replacement or a refund. Our products have thousands of positive reviews on our site and on Nordstrom.com, which means that this experience you describe is not happening to the majority of our customers. In regards to our customer service, we are only available weekdays. The delay you experienced was probably over the weekend. We are truly sorry for this and would love to help you out. Please send over a direct message so we can further assist.
Best
Sole Society

Thumbnail of user simplyj
1 review
1 helpful vote
April 20th, 2017

The worst thing I have ever done was making a decision to purchase the mason sole society vegan travel satchel. I'm an individual who takes pride spending my money on possessions. This bag is high priced and low quality... I'm disappointed and dissatisfied after having my bag for a short period of time. The zipper is jammed, the teeth are misaligned and separated and I can't fix it.

Thumbnail of user miac7
CustomerCare -. – Sole Society Rep

Hello! We are so sorry to hear that your item is defective. We will send you a private message to further discuss this. Thanks! - Sole Society

Thumbnail of user tiffanyv45
1 review
6 helpful votes
December 20th, 2019

I received a pair of shoes I ordered and they did not fit right so I sent them back. After 3 weeks, i did not yet receive a refund. After countless calls waiting to speak with someone for over 25min rach time, i never was able to get a hold of someone. Never had a history of my return and never recieved any emails back that I sent about my return. Luckily I paid through paypal so I filed a claim and within 10 days of them not hearing from the company, PayPal refunded me the money. I still havent heard back from Sole Society. Good luck with a return!

Thumbnail of user karam67
1 review
12 helpful votes
October 30th, 2018

I placed an order for two pairs of shoes and sent them back the very next day when I realized they didn't fit. It's now a month later and I STILL have not received my refund.

Thumbnail of user nancyt600
1 review
2 helpful votes
December 16th, 2019

I Bought a pair of boots online. They came very quickly, and were a good quality. 2 Days later they were on sale 50.00 less. Tried calling there customer service but the phone # kept disconnecting due to high call volume. I email customer service and received a reply quickly stating they do NOT give price adjustments. I can send them back at my expense and repurchase them. I will not buy from them again.

Nancy T

Thumbnail of user miac7
CustomerCare -. – Sole Society Rep

Hi Nancy! Unfortunately, during heavy promotional seasons, we are unable to honor any promotions for orders placed outside of the promotional time frame as this would be unfair to the rest of our customers. We’re so sorry for any inconvenience, and appreciate your understanding! However, we are happy to help out with the return fee. Send over an email to sos@solesociety.com for further assistance.

Thumbnail of user chrisl746
1 review
1 helpful vote
December 23rd, 2019

Checked the website made sure the order came through before 7 am pst... paid extra for 2 day shipping, and 2 days later the item still hasn't shipped. I go to call Customer support surprise surprise they are currently closed for the holiday...

Thumbnail of user miac7
CustomerCare -. – Sole Society Rep

Chris- Sorry about the bad experience! Please send an email to sos@solesociety.com with your order number and we will get back to you ASAP.

Thumbnail of user mem184
1 review
5 helpful votes
January 8th, 2018

Sole society is spamming my mailbox everyday it seems. I dont know how they got my address. I would never buy anything from them. And even when I try to unsubscribe and block, SS evidently makes that impossible. I hate SS.

Thumbnail of user gilliana60
2 reviews
0 helpful votes
March 5th, 2020

I ordered the lacie weekender bag and I love it. It is great quality and feels and looks like real leather although it is vegan. I was concerned about purchasing from them after seeing these reviews but I personally thought it was great and the bag i purchased is definitely worth the money.

Products used:
Lacie weekender bag

Service
Value
Shipping
Quality
Thumbnail of user miac7
CustomerCare -. – Sole Society Rep

Hi Gillian, thank you so much for sharing your experience and for taking a pic of one of our best sellers! You made our day. :)

Thumbnail of user janicem89
1 review
4 helpful votes
August 22nd, 2017

Shoes didn't fit right, and then of course had to pay to return, so I paid $8.00 just to try on. Spent almost 45 minutes trying to find how to return. Impossible. Click on something that leads to nothing. It showed I had no orders placed, What? I have no orders placed? What am I holding in my hand trying to return? Wish I would have read all the bad reviews first. DON'T BUY FROM THIS COMPANY.

Thumbnail of user juliea119
1 review
5 helpful votes
July 12th, 2017

The shoes are crap and don't fit properly. I made the mistake of waiting to return them... I got them right before vacation and thought I had time. As it turns out, they have a 30-day return policy, which is WAY more restrictive than others - especially Zappos. I tried to return them today, 45 days after my order date, and I can't. BIG SCAM! Here's a tip for you Sole Society... it's not about your policies, it's about the customer. Zappos is a market leader for a reason, and as long as you make things inconvenient for the customer, your business will never survive.

Thumbnail of user debrac78
1 review
2 helpful votes
June 3rd, 2017

I am unhappy with my purchase of Jillian boogie and Barcelona suede wedge. Unless you have a very narrow foot width, order a 1/2 size up. These shoes did not run true to size and were very narrow in the tie box. I'm now stuck with two pairs of shoes I cannot exchange for a larger size because they were in "final sale". Won't be shopping this site again.

Thumbnail of user christinal226
1 review
4 helpful votes
November 17th, 2019

I have tried and tried to place online orders at Sole Society over the last month and the orders never go through. I have tried different browsers, cleared caches, different computers, tried different payment methods, manually entering my information and absolutely nothing works. I emailed them the error message I kept receiving and they said I can call my order in on the next business day. I have never had such issues trying to place orders with a website. I contacted them when this first happened. Nothing changed. I gave it another try this weekend which is about 2-3 weeks from the last time I tried and still having the same issue. It's totally frustrating. I can't be the only person having these issues?!

Sitejabber for Business

Gain trust and grow your business with customer reviews.

From the business

We believe there is a better way to style: that you can have the look you want without overspending or sacrificing on quality. Shop the latest in women's shoes, apparel, bags & more at Sole Society.

Company Representative

Thumbnail of user miac7
CustomerCare -.
Typically does not respond to reviews

How do I know I can trust these reviews about Sole Society?

  • Sitejabber’s sole mission is to increase online transparency for buyers and businesses
  • Sitejabber has helped over 200M buyers make better purchasing decisions online
  • Suspicious reviews are flagged by our algorithms, moderators, and community members
Have a question about Sole Society?