Stila Cosmetics

Bought 3 things recently, but the eyeshadow makeup was sooo bad, made me frustrated. Poor quality and doesn't last at all. Do not buy it!

I've been using Stila for years now and you cannot beat the quality. Crazy pigmented and lasts for hours on end, even in the heat of the summer. It's a little pricey but it lasts!

Bought 2 eyeshadows from them. Really like the colors but after three uses - FOR both colors - the tip of the wand broke off. That is why they had the eyeshadows marked 1/2 price. When contacted? Didn't ask for replacement shadow, only for replacement wands. BUT oh no, they wanted pictures, return shipping on their clients just not worth the hassle. Would never buy from them again.

Liquid eyeshadow is gorgeous but it's really expensive, so it's an investment to buy more than one. The eyeliner is pretty similar to kat von d tattoo liner

If you order from this company they will never give you a return label if your products are unused, and you change your mind. Buyer beware

I ordered their new lip liner and when it arrived it wasn't what I ordered, they had an issue with the site and had the color swatches named wrong they emailed and I emailed back to say I received the wrong color nut they had already sent me another lipliner well it was processing the same wrong color fyi I tried to stop them I had photos of my order the showed the obvious mistake they shipped the same wrong color again, ignored my emails for two weeks. They had it the colors wrong on their website knew they. Made a mistake and couldn't care less, clearly business isn't going so well for them but its clear why.

I have bought from their website multiple times and never has an issue. Items always ship fast and they are always exactly as described and wrapped very carefully (in pretty stila paper too).

Don't get their shimmery eye shadows. Got a huge bacterial eye infection that caused me to miss a day of work. The company hasn't responded to my detailed email.

I decided to try out a stila eyeliner, and at first it worked sooo well. It was a rich dark color that stayed on even if i didn't touch up during the day. I thought i finally found the eyeliner to for me. But after some uses (can't approximate how many... mm every other day for 2 months?) it started to break off as i was applying it! No bueno, esp for something i put on the inside of my eyes!

First and last order... they cancelled with no notice. Be warned about their terrible customer service. Wish I knew before I tried to order. I will never ever purchase Stila products again.

AVOID

I ordered two items from the Stila site on 7-20. Nine days later, the items still hadn't shipped so I sent Stila an email canceling my order. Within one hour of sending the email, they shipped my order and answered my cancellation email stating they couldn't cancel my order because it had already been sent. That seemed suspect, but I accepted it. I received the items and didn't like either - both were chocked full of glitter and just not my style. Most companies send prepaid return labels or at least include a return address on the invoice. Not Stila. You have to contact them to not only get their return address, but you must tell them what you're returning and why and get an "authorization number" that MUST be included with your return or it won't be accepted. The best part is you only have seven days from when you were given the authorization number to return your items. I've dealt with sites with this irritating policy before, so I already knew what to do. I sent my items back quickly and wrote that silly "authorization" number everywhere - on the invoice and on the back and front of the envelope. Stila received my package two days after I sent it. About two weeks later, I got my refund. Naturally, shipping costs weren't refunded and I had to spend $7 to return the items. So why is it I had to send the items back within seven days, but Stila's return department sits on the items for two weeks?

Frankly, I find companies that use this "send the items back now with this much needed number on it, but we'll take our time refunding you" to be scammy. They're hoping you'll forget to send the item within the seven days or won't include the number so they don't have to refund you. There are far too many companies and sites that have truly hassle free returns and those are the ones I deal with. Stila products have been iffy for the better part of a decade now anyway but if you love them, I suggest buying them from Sephora or any other site that doesn't have these jump-through-hoops return policy that ends up costing you money.

My go to liquid eye shadows are extremely beautiful! A little pricy for one but definitely worth it and last all day!

They sent me a broken eyeshadow palette and basically told me to go f myself and did not want to replace it for me.

Obsessed about liquid eyeshadow that wont smear or the glitter wont flake put or fade away? Stilas most popular is the diamond and rose gold

I've purchased every long-handled makeup brush Stila has available. These are my absolute favorite brushes in my collection even compared to Shu, Trish McEvoy, MAC, etc. Their customer service has always gone above and beyond to make any wrongs right.