• UNTUCKit

UNTUCKit

Overview

UNTUCKit has a rating of 1.86 stars from 51 reviews, indicating that most customers are generally dissatisfied with their purchases. Reviewers complaining about UNTUCKit most frequently mention customer service problems. UNTUCKit ranks 835th among Clothing Other sites.

  • Service
    17
  • Value
    18
  • Shipping
    16
  • Returns
    13
  • Quality
    18

This company does not typically respond to reviews

Positive reviews (last 12 months): 0%
Positive
0
Neutral
0
Negative
5
10
See all photos
How would you rate UNTUCKit?
Top Positive Review

“Love the shirts, but disappointed by Customer Service”

Frank S.
1/7/23

I discovered Untuckit.com two months ago. I love the shirts. I found the right size. It was a good look for me. The price is a little high but generally I'm happy with the product. However, I ordered a Full Zip Fleece Sweater on an expedited shipment (2 day) expecting it before New Years Eve. I got a completely different product. My experience with Customer Service was negative. They didn't understand I needed them by New Years Eve, and said they could ship me the correct product in 5-10 days.

Top Critical Review

“ABSOLUTE GARBAGE”

Brian P.
1/25/23

I had 4 UNTUCKit shirts. I really liked the way they looked and fit but, thought they felt a little flimsy. I guess it wasn't my imagination. The elbow has ripped in 3 of the 4. I suppose I'll continue wearing the last one until that elbow goes as well... I'm not a big guy and the size was right. I only have pics of the 2 because I already trashed the other 1. Both of these ripped within the last week so I still have them.

Reviews (51)

Rating

Timeframe

Other

Thumbnail of user jtat823
1 review
0 helpful votes
February 7th, 2024

I was really looking forward to wearing these shirts. I ordered two of them: a long sleeve polo and a long sleeve button down. The polo fit perfectly out of the package- just arrived today. I washed it and dried it according to instructions (tumble dry on medium heat)- and it shrank so much it is comical. I put it on and by stomach shows. This isn't normal shrinking you see with cotton- this is comical! I haven't washed the button down- and will not wear it now anyway. Untuckit got my money this time, but they won't get more. These shirts are trash. Buy something else.

Thumbnail of user rosalynw36
1 review
0 helpful votes
December 22nd, 2023

Placed order on December 19,2023. Paid for expedited shipping, 2 day shipping. Got notified today it just shipped and will arrive after Christmas. Should have been notified immediately so I could have shopped elsewhere.

Thumbnail of user dneufman
1 review
0 helpful votes
December 8th, 2023

A recent purchase was very late & they gave me a 25% discount. Then ordered over $500 and paid to expedite and it was only shipped after it was to have been delivered; Since I used the 25% coupon they gave me I was precluded from using the holiday discount. So no goods arrived for which I paid to expedite delivery and now need to shop for the gifts I don't have for my sons. So I asked for the discount again since I used it on goods that didn't arrive timely. After more than 30 minutes of time chatting with two people, they could not agree to anything. So frankly their conduct is shameful.; Don't buy from them if you expect your order to be timely received, even if they charge you extra for that.

Tip for consumers:
They waste time with chatting service that has no authority to do anything other than make you wait and answer questions.....

Products used:
As of today I have not received the items - indeed,they admit they only shipped them to me today!

Thumbnail of user sheilaf369
1 review
0 helpful votes
January 30th, 2024

I purchased two shirts as a Christmas gift for my son---both were the same size, XL, regular fit, based on their sizing chart. One fit okay but the other shirt was way too small in the sleeves and tight overall. It seems to me that based on their sizing chart, two shirts of the same size and fit should FIT THE SAME! Both my son and I have made attempts to exchange the one shirt or get a credit for a future purchase but to no avail. I can understand why there would be no refunds on final sale items, but why would it hurt to EXCHANGE the shirt for a larger size or fit?

Apparently. There is no room in their policy (as with the one shirt) for exchanging a final sale item. So BEWARE, if you purchase a final sale item, be prepared to donate it or gift it to someone else if it doesn't fit the person it was bought for! Perhaps that's why they are final sale items---the sizing is incorrect and they need to move them out?

Thumbnail of user brianp1993
1 review
3 helpful votes
January 25th, 2023
Verified purchase

I had 4 UNTUCKit shirts. I really liked the way they looked and fit but, thought they felt a little flimsy. I guess it wasn't my imagination. The elbow has ripped in 3 of the 4. I suppose I'll continue wearing the last one until that elbow goes as well... I'm not a big guy and the size was right. I only have pics of the 2 because I already trashed the other 1. Both of these ripped within the last week so I still have them.

Thumbnail of user jackb1695
1 review
2 helpful votes
February 5th, 2023
Verified purchase

I recently received a shirt and pair pants from Untuckit as a gift. The shirt didn't fit and I wanted to return it, but found out it was not eligible for return. Don't understand why you can't return the item for a different size or style, especially at their prices. So I returned both the shirt and the pants. They can just have the shirt back. I have other UNTUCKit items that I purchased, but those will be the last item I ever buy from them.

Thumbnail of user pamelac1769
1 review
4 helpful votes
December 16th, 2022
Verified purchase

We purchased from Untuckit at a mall in Atlanta for my husband. We purchased 2 dress shirts and 2 sweaters. I asked the sales person when checking out if the sweaters were washable, I should have looked at the tag, but she said yes, she thought so, just wash on delicate. So, I washed them on gentle cycle, cold water, laid them flat to dry. They both shrunk up by at least 2 sizes. My husband never even got to wear them. These were expensive shirts/sweaters. Same thing with the dress shirts. They shrunk as well and also washed on cold water, gentle cycle. Will not waste my money there ever again!

Tip for consumers:
Avoid this store! The quality of the items do not warrant the prices they charge.

Products used:
dress shirts and sweaters

Service
Value
Quality
Thumbnail of user richw221
1 review
0 helpful votes
February 27th, 2023

I went to the location at Tysons corner va. The Clerk assured me the shirt would NOT shrink. 100% amd said I should stick with the large. Well folks it shrunk and I followed the label for cleaning. Staff are misinformed and poorly trained. But one size up. I have two shirts I can't wear and I'm out $200.

Products used:
Long sleeve shirts

Service
Value
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user vincentm380
1 review
1 helpful vote
September 15th, 2021
Verified purchase

I placed an order on 9/7/2021 and was scheduled to receive on 9/10/2021. This was later changed to 9/15/2021 (today). Its again changed to 9/21/2021. On contacting UNTUCKit, they are blaming UPS. I have no sale contract with UPS. This is my first time purchase from UNTUCKit... utter disappointment. I will promptly return the items as soon as I receive them, if ever.

Tip for consumers:
They blame UPS for poor/no delivery

Service
Shipping
Thumbnail of user abbytaiwo3
1 review
0 helpful votes
June 8th, 2023

Someone referred me to this website and I tried to make a purchase using a Vanilla Gift-card and it's wouldn't allow me to do it, so I was refer to a live chat representative to assist. I have gave all the information about the gift card then I change my mind and asked her to cancel my order and credit my card and nothing happens. I called them for help and send a screenshot of the charges to the card and still nothing. I was told that they couldn't help me, that i needed to call the gift card customer service. I will never shop with them again. One and done. I lost $66 dollars of my gift card.

Thumbnail of user paull2218
1 review
1 helpful vote
January 6th, 2023
Verified purchase

I placed an order due to a TV Commercial and I received my order today. I ordered XXL and the shirts run really small! So if you normally wear L get an XXL and if you wear a XXL like me get an XXXXL. Their models must have been very small men

Tip for consumers:
Shirts run extemely smal

Products used:
Shirts

Value
Shipping
Quality
Thumbnail of user mitchb62
1 review
1 helpful vote
November 28th, 2020

I really like the shirts and would give them 5 stars however, the majority are made in China hence the lower rating. I do not want to buy any products made in China. Bring back the made in USA shirts. I will pay more for them!

Thumbnail of user patrickc342
1 review
0 helpful votes
October 2nd, 2022
Verified purchase

I purchased several items from Untuckit to try them out. They have a process that estimates your size, and I used it. It seemed small for me, so I ordered items in their size recommendation and my own. It turns out that their recommendations were far too small (and no, I didn't lie about my weight or how big my stomach is). This is no big deal, but what is the deal breaker for me is that several of the items I purchased are "unreturnable" even though they haven't been opened or worn. This wasn't flagged or in any way brought to my attention when I purchased them. Since I paid full price, these weren't even cheap discount items. Really awful policy for an on-line clothing store. There are plenty of other options out there if you like nice shirts that you can wear untucked, don't risk your money here.

Tip for consumers:
Don't. Do. It. Plenty of other folks sell shirts that look nice untucked and treat you much better.

Products used:
Couldn't return shirts that didn't fit, used them for rags to clean my car.

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user kenr519
1 review
1 helpful vote
January 20th, 2023

These shirts belong in your rag pile
Quality is low
Price is extremely high
Shrinks one size
Purchase an iron to get out the locked in wrinkles and re-shape the collar

Thumbnail of user robertm7910
1 review
0 helpful votes
April 4th, 2023

I ordered 2 XXL shirts...I usually wear xl so I was planning on being able to wear it loosely. Shirts came in and I can barely even button them. No way I'm wearing them and they feel lightweight and cheap.

Thumbnail of user ds1399
1 review
1 helpful vote
December 12th, 2022

My main beef is they censor bad reviews from their website, so all you see is 4 and 5 star reviews. I posted a review on the Marty, got email confirmation that it was there, and I had a feeling this was going to happen because nobody no matter how good you are, has ZERO negative reviews, and sure enough it was taken down. Just maybe go to a store and not order online, these items are not made for "men", they're made for hipsters with noodle arms. I ordered a 2XL expecting something like this to happen and it was still to small in the arms to where when you try to give a hug, that motion, it feels like you're going to blowout the shoulder seams. Very disappointing because the style and quality seemed to be great.

Tip for consumers:
Go to the physical store if you can and try the items yourself. Since they censor reviews on their web site, you won't get the whole truth from consumers.

Products used:
I bought the Marty jacket, not using it.

Value
Shipping
Quality
Thumbnail of user kt291
1 review
1 helpful vote
November 28th, 2022

Poor corporate response to easily solved issue created by untuckit. Store ordered pants, they never arrived. Company can't figure out how to get me the merchandise or credit my card

Thumbnail of user scotta1243
1 review
0 helpful votes
January 11th, 2023

I purchased two of the long sleeve "wrinkle free" non dress shirts before Christmas. I wore them and followed the cleaning instructions carefully. These shirts are not wrinkle free at all. I will not buy these shirts again.

Products used:
None

Service
Value
Quality
Thumbnail of user brucef362
1 review
1 helpful vote
February 17th, 2022

I wrote to untuckit about a shirt that had worn prematurely. All I wanted was a replacement and all I got was the run around. Too bad for them. I had been a good customer but no more. Sent them several messages but they obviously couldn't care less. Lots of other places to do business.

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user davidt2926
1 review
0 helpful votes
June 15th, 2022

Such a shame that I have to unsubscribe both our accounts. Having found some excellent products from UNTUCKit, with such an investment in assisting with correct sizing, I. Made the simple request to stop the useless email marketing from the. Com, USA side of the company. No use, and promoting products not available here in the UK, especially Women's wear - which could be viewed as saving me money, but still frustrating.
Could this be communicated, no, anybody listen, no, anybody interested in feedback, constructive or otherwise, no. Emails copied, for weeks now, to management, no response, no interest at all.
Given this, and the plethora of other options, it will be untucked shirts from anyone but UNTUCKit from now on.
It was not like this in the beginning but, as often happens, companies have success, grow, and then cannot cope with customer care any longer.
This will only get worse, but the good news is that for all people out there, prices will start to tumble, but without any customer care or interest this will only sustain them short term.
Remember, as many other reviews say, UNTUCKit sizing is different, good when you find the right one, but getting there with any number of returns, exchanges, refunds, shortages of stock along the way will be very difficult given the absence of customer care / service.
Best avoid, sorry
Update:

AND it gets worse, no contact, no response, no interest only more and more unwarranted marketing emails, cannot stop them.
All businesses make mistakes, all have problems, and how they deal with them sets them apart, but NEVER have I experienced a company who do not listen, and where you cannot "reach higher" to someone that does give a ****, as they remain faceless and anonymous to contact!
And remember the products are good, once you get the right size but, as already said, unless you get it right every time, or should you need customer support for anything, forget it!
Such a shame.
You will however get to know which customer care agents like "cats", walking, outdoors or any number of personal details which, without any listening or actual customer care, is really just pointless, irritating and patronising!

Tip for consumers:
Avoid if any chance you might need any customer service!

Products used:
Shirts, polos, trousers, shorts.

Thumbnail of user jamesv1159
1 review
0 helpful votes
September 4th, 2022

ZERO STARS
These shirts are the same size as a normal cut shirt and none of them sat where they should below the belt line. The slim fit were cut big. I made the mistake of ordering 6 of shirts and don't like any of them. Lesson learned.

Thumbnail of user caito
2 reviews
10 helpful votes
June 17th, 2021

I've tried to forgive the incompetence this company exhibits but at this point it's not possible. After messing up my order, sending it to the wrong address, not mitigating the issue, and now blatantly ignoring my emails with customer service reps, I've had enough. It appears I'll never get my $200 back, or the products that they never sent.

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user nickp736
1 review
2 helpful votes
May 21st, 2022
Verified purchase

Claim their shirts are wrinkle free, quite the opposite, very prone to excessive wrinkles and shirts run very small. Not high quality material. $20 shirts with a $90 price tag.

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user gerardp103
1 review
0 helpful votes
February 11th, 2023

I LOVED THE LOOK OF UNTUCKIT SHIRTS BUY TO CARE FIR THEM IS HORRIBLE. IF YOU WASH THEM IN COLD WATER THEY SHRINK 2 INCHES ON THE SLEEVES. I HAVED PURCHASED THESE SHIRTS FOR YEARS FOR WORK BECAUSE I ALWAYS RECEIVED A COMPLIMENT ON YHE FIT BUT I AM DONE WITH THEM. WASTED A LOT OF MONEY ON SHRINKING SHIRTS BUY LANDS END SHIRTS

Tip for consumers:
All of their shirts shrink in cold water wash. Don’t buy

Products used:
Shirts

Service
Value
Shipping
Returns
Quality
Thumbnail of user josieb94
1 review
0 helpful votes
December 28th, 2022

Try it on in store if possible! Bought the shirt for my man for Christmas he wears a double XXL And it fits like a large, give me a break so disappointing! Thankful he has somebody he can give it to because I hate taking stuff back

Products used:
A gray pink striped shirt

Service
Value
Quality

Sitejabber for Business

Gain trust and grow your business with customer reviews.

From the business

Casual men's shirts designed to be worn untucked. Regular and Slim fit button-downs, sweaters, tees, henleys and polos. Now offering Women's button-down shirts. UNTUCKit offers 13 product categories—ranging from T-shirts and polos to sports jackets and pants—in addition to a wide selection of shirts, dresses and blazers for women.
All UNTUCKit product is designed in-house at our New York City Headquarters. Our fabrics are made exclusively for us by top-tier manufacturers across the world—all of whom adhere to strict social and environmental guidelines. We test every batch of fabric to ensure the best possible quality and consistency, so all of our button-downs, polos, tees, Henleys, and more have that just-right length and fit perfectly

Business History

WE STARTED UNTUCKIT….
…because we couldn’t find shirts that looked good untucked. It’s a tough style to get right. That’s why we created the perfect untucked shirt. It has that just-right length, fits all shapes and sizes, and helps you look sharp—even at your most casual.

WE’VE COME A LONG WAY…... from 2010 when founder Chris Riccobono first created the Original Untucked Shirt. In 2011, he brought on Aaron Sanandres, a classmate from Columbia University, to help him develop the idea into a stand alone business. We opened our first store in 2015 in SoHo, and since then we’ve employed more than 700 people across 70-plus stores in North America, as well as our New York City headquarters. We’re excited to share our next steps, made possible by everyone who enjoys the polished look and casual feel of our signature untucked shirts.

Company Representative

Thumbnail of user albertoc31
Alberto C.
Typically does not respond to reviews

How do I know I can trust these reviews about UNTUCKit?

  • Sitejabber’s sole mission is to increase online transparency for buyers and businesses
  • Sitejabber has helped over 200M buyers make better purchasing decisions online
  • Suspicious reviews are flagged by our algorithms, moderators, and community members

See reviews as you browse with our Chrome extension

1.9
51 reviews
Have a question about UNTUCKit?