Searched for an event at a local venue on Google. Got TicketSales.com instead of the venue. Found the event I wanted and ordered 2 tickets for $83.79.
Later, friends shared that the ticket prices they bought were only $12 each! Sure enough, going to the venue's actual website confirmed this price!
BOY DO I FEEL LIKE A SUCKER... VERY PISSED!
Of course, the tickets are non-refundable. I still haven't received the tickets by email so I don't know if I will actually receive them or not.