I am editing this as True Classic Tees customer service reached out to us a day or two after I posted this. They wanted to make our order right. We were sent the appropriate size of shirts in a timely manner. We offered to send the other shirts back but we were told to donate them to a charitable organization. Thank you for correcting the mistake.
*My husband is always on the lookout for a nice fitting T-shirt so when I saw the ads for True Classics I told him he needed to order some. We did the sizing and followed the measurement guide and he ordered one, when he ordered there was an offer to add a surprise for an additional $8.99 so he did. They showed up today and he texted me at work to tell me that one shirt would fit a 350 pound man (subtract 130 lbs from that for my husband) and one would probably fit me (115 lbs) as they sent a size small. He is really disappointed and I do not know how you can follow the website's sizing guide and end up with a shirt that does not fit and why they would send a completely different sized shirt as the surprise (I guess that is the surprise?). So apparently do not fall for the hype around these shirts.
Hi there! It looks like size small was ordered for the navy tee, and 2xl was ordered for the mystery tee! Our fulfillment team fulfills orders according to how they were placed. No worries if that wasn’t the size you intended to order, we’ll get the right sizes out, on us!