Ponyisland is your average breeding game. The artwork is nice and the breeding options are plentiful. The designers of the website do a great job, and the art community is extremely talented. It is nothing special, and I recommend other websites like Flight Rising as I find they have more to offer.
At the end of the day, the game is fine but the MODS are HORRIBLE and ultimately are unwilling to hear out players and make the experience nearly unbearable. I quit after years of playing because the MODS were so terrible. They play favorites, and unless you kiss up to them they WILL make your experience an unpleasant one.
At the end of the day, invest your money into websites where the staff care and are helpful/