Here’s what consumers have asked with answers from Naturalizer staff and previous consumers.
Heya! I'm also a 7.5 but when I got my Naturalizer heels I got a size 7 and even those have a bit of room. I got these extra pads that go underneath the front part of my foot and the shoe fits perfectly. Definitely size down.
I've bought this brand twice and both times the shoes didn't last. First time it was a normal work wear pair which I thought felt very comfortable. The heel support screw snapped within 5 weeks and they went to the rubbish. The second time, I bought slip ons and after the first wear the insole lifted and started to come off and the cushioning underneath started crumbling